Welcome to Crestfall Gaming

Register now to Crestfall Gaming. Once registered and logged in, you will be able to contribute to this site by submitting your own content or replying to existing content. You'll be able to customize your profile, receive reputation points as a reward for submitting content, while also communicating with other members via your own private inbox, plus much more! This message will be removed once you have signed in.

Polyphem

Member
  • Content count

    63
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Community Reputation

83 Excellent

About Polyphem

  • Rank
    Sergeant
  1. Looking at the time you reacted on the closing I thought you meant the post that was full of racial escalations aso.? This one was obviously closed for good reasons.
  2. The author of this topic has created his account on Sunday - sayings like "this is the final nail in the coffin for us" feel really out of place. Normally somebody who wasn't active in the forums but lurked around for quite some time ("passive" member of community if you will) at least makes this clear in his first posts, especially when using words like "us" so freely. His other two posts show the same attitude when he is warning us "friends" from Darkrasps "banning-spree" and he's badmouthing the team in the name of the community... I feels like an Undermining of the community and its relationship to the team... and it gets viral without counterbalances anymore :(. /edit: @Blademastaz: Ok, now you a dressed it ... still it feels somewhat off
  3. Might be, but actually i think the major thing that decides about the influx of Elysium-players on Crestfall at launch won't be the possibility for PTE, but rather the chance to play on a completely new core. So unless Elysium-TBC and Crestfall-Vanilla won't launch at around the same time (2 months or so), so that there could be serious competition about at what shiny place one wants to invest his time, i don't see a huge impact here. But another thing that i find interesting about this announcement is the capabilities of the Elysium-Team to realize a TBC-server. As it was stated in many Crestfall-Developer-posts by Darkrasp, there was much development already going on for TBC parallel to that of Vanilla, while i never heard about work on TBC from the side of Elysium. -> The timing of the Ely-BC-announcement shortly after the merge with Crestfall raises many question marks about the involvement of Crestfall-technology in this. Does Elysium plan to use the Benediction-Core with its already working TBC-mechanics from Crestfall for the new Addon? (There would be enough time for the merge of technology and team until then) I think this could be a good question for the next Q&A (if there will be another Q&A that is :/). Another note on the development in this forums: I increasingly feel bad about the atmosphere here - also there are many "new accounts" with dubious actions. Also i feel like the counterbalance to this from the community itself is slowly fading ... Maybe i'm over exaggerating, i'm not sure...
  4. Well, why to close the Crestfall-Update-topic in the first place? There were many productive discussions on it - and it's really hard to put out a final statement in that lengthy attitude like Darkrasp did and in the same moment stripping the community of the chance to relate and answer to it... this is simply not good and leads to even more frustration, because it is essentially the same as to say "go fuck yourselves" (Because this is the only way for a community to openly discuss and to form itself - in the same way it is poison to delete stuff which thankfully never happened here). Even if Elicas is maybe somewhat biased because of his former involvement in a project he can no longer relate to (just guessing, could be wrong), it's another thing and wrong to deny his post any meaning behind personal frustration - because this is what you essentially do and imply when you simply attack him on a personal level in a manner as if that could refute his post. Greetings
  5. Keep cool, man. First you critizise someone for writing "inflammatory" texts while the very same post of you seems to be the very same thing you're ciritzising (oh i hate that word in english, never sure i write it correctly). You embarrass yourself :(. And please explain to me how the deletion of posts is in any way comparable with a reputation system? (That is of course, if one doesn't assume that every reputation given is artificially constructed by bots or whatnot - if one has this attitude he already lost trust in anything that builds up a community) As for the concern, that the majority of Crestfall-players would be former Elysium-players anyway, thats a legit point - I see it the following: Of course there would have been many ppl that would swap over in time, but this step would have probably taken "some" time that allowed for "some" adaption - i don't want to overemphasize it though. Also the question of a VPN-block being intact is a major thing that under the current circumstances is pretty unclear (Elysium will have to tell all their chinese players, that they are not allowed to play on Crestfall - it is one thing to tell a certain group of people to stay out from the beginning while it is a completely other thing to tell already involved people that they are not welcomed on the communities recent and newest development - this could be a major concern and i don't know if Elysium will uphold the VPN-block for the Crestfall realm under that circumstances.) -> But still, as it was said by some people before me, and as you also indicated, the server-start of a popular project is always a major stress-test for the previously build up community and its values. The 're are positive and negative examples for this (funny enough i see Kronos as a positive example here in contrast to Nostalrius - but then again Nostalrius had many more ppl that played upon it in the beginning). Under Elysium this ideal of a community is less likely to outlast than it was (even) before and the dissolution of our forum and integration in the elysium one seems like some kind of gravestone to this community even though it could be otherwise (This forum seems to be the very core structure of the community, and i don't talk about the mechanics given to us but the organic growing that is reflected in all the posts, bonds, the reputation system(!) aso - as Outstanding said in the according, latest Update-Topic: It takes a lot of time to build something special and only moments to tear it down ... or something in that manner^^). Greetings
  6. One reason why this post of "Forest_" appears so toxic to us, is because their is no reputation-system intact on the Elysium-Forums. I pointed this out in another topic some time ago - To give reputation to posts is one of the few ways for a community to organize itself and push demands to the staff in a reasonable way. -> Nobody knows how many people identify with "forest_" on this matter and so he will seem to some of the people here as the standard Elysium-Plebs - resulting in a wrong picture of their community, while he's maybe a tiny minority. -> Also if there's a reputation-system moderators will think twice before banning popular opinions because they can see for themselves that they might upset many ppl (of course only if a comment ha some time to have impact - if its deleted after 10-30 minutes, welcome North Korea... Elysiums April Fools becoming real). Greetings
  7. @cybaster It seems to me, that you have a history of your own on Elysium, so i'm not sure if there is any bad blood between you and some members of the staff. Also your post, even in its toned down version is still quite demanding and provocative ... But still it is no good sign, that they delete your post instead of defusing it with arguments, this makes me concerned too. Greetings
  8. Oh, thanks for the info :D. I'm still skeptical regarding the her influence, because her resignation sounds awkwardly pathetic and misleading regarding the real things behind the curtain... Maybe some People, that currently play on Elysium can share their newest experiences there. Greetings
  9. It is indeed the crux of the matter. And if you were already there when Crestfall announced the "Legacy Crusade Project" (somewhat of a merge between Elysium and Crestfall Project) at the beginning of this year, you know that there is no guarantee. There were two major reactions to the announcement back then: The first one was utter disappointment and even some aggression (to a lower extent - the community here is not that toxic), the second one was a pledge for more insight into the details of the merge and the answer to the question how the "standards of this community/project" can be upheld under the influence from Elysium. The result to me at least was, that there were no guarantees the team could give. Nobody knows how the new influence of Elysium will play out. I'ts important to remember, that decision-making is not based on rules that were set up in advance, but on the persons that are in charge and therefore hold power (because of financial capability, technical know-how, investment of time or simple strength of argumentation as you can see to some extent even with some known community-members here, who even rose up to be part of the team). The only thing you as a member can do is the following: 1. Find out who holds the threads 2. Investigate if this person/these persons share your own philosophy concerning a good WoW-Server/Community 3. If yes, stay with the project (if not, leave it alone - as many of you will have in the blink of an eye with many servers on your search for the "real thing") 4. If this trusted authority changes his philosophy on the way, try to influence through the community if you cannot accept this change 5. If this trusted authority steps back, identify the knew authority and repeat the procedure. In the current situation it seems to me, that point 5 is the case, but nobody really knows who is the new authority (because naturally you can only tell after the merge has completed to some extent). There are some reflections on this as given by Xaverius - - but ultimately this is only a good guess at how things will play out. Maybe this is also the reason why Darkrasp is so cautious with his own words as you can see here (i shortened his q&a for the sake of clarity - i have no intention to quote somebody out of context!) Expressions like "as far as i know", "no changes have been requested" (so far?) and "unlikely/possible at some point" give me the impression that even Darkrasp is not sure at all what will really be the case after the merge. And i personally doubt, that there is a chance at all to prevent influence from Elysium after the merge. Another point is, that no matter the outcome, the communities will merge instantaneously without any chance of slow adaption to the predominant values of the Crestfall Community (to exaggerate a little bit - that's the fear many people have when thinking of Elysium - that you will get all the hackers, bothers, china farmers aso.). I also find the idea highly unlikely, that Elysium will exclude a huge part of their player base (the Chinese) from the new core and scripts because of Crestfall philosophy... Concerning the predominant figures at Elysium, i am not really up to date, but there seem to be some changes? Sounds like the Elysiumstaff is much more trustworthy now, but Shenna is still in charge? I know it was a drastic cut into the private sphere, but the leaked sound-file with the discussion of the Elysium-staff and Crogge about the "shady money stuff" showed to me, that Shenna is pretty authoritarian and not always open to reason. Crogge gave ample explanation back then for recording the logs and that there should be no possibility for single members to erase that data (which obviously would enable these team-members to do as they like without anybody being able to find them guilty - i hope i remember that part correctly) and still she rejected it back then and demanded allegiance from the other members no matter what (or they could leave). -> I don't trust her. So if possible, i would be glad to read what the real differences are besides Vitaly being removed (which doesn't solve anything - if the structure is rotten, the people abusing this are only the secondary problem). Of course i would also like to hear, what position Crogge will hold concerning the new project. For the sake of it i also have to mention that Crogge, although he seemed really reasonable in the leaked audio-file mostly is a big question mark to me. Maybe it's because i'm not part of the first generation of forum-members, but i rarely heard any opinion from him concerning his philosophy of Crestfall. Asura, although he rarely posted something himself, seemed much more related to that philosophy, maybe also because his close ties to Darkrasp. The last thing i want to mention is the already posted disregard of the community by the team: First i need to say, that the team with all his flaws has done a better job reaching out to such a big community as any other private-server-team i remember (if there were only a few followers of course it could have been much more familiar). I don't want o feign compassion and loyalty as some other people might have done in this topic, but seeing people like Elicas and Outstanding being raised into the ranks they held for some time (Community Manager) shows a genuine interest from the team for their connection with this special community. Probably this was more because of Darkrasp than because of Asura... But looking back now i also have the feeling, that this repetitive process of presenting complete turnarounds to the community without any prior talks is damaging for the relationship between team and community. I remember, that Asura himself announced the first LGN out of nowhere and in that topic he sounded quite enthusiastic about it. It seemed as if he had simply forgotten about the community having a mind of its own. I cannot say the same goes for the present situation, but again it's Asura presenting the facts without any connection to the community. -> Long story short: Outstanding, even though he can be a bit arrogant from time to time, was right in his judgment, that the whole system suffers from the "split-person-syndrome" between Asura and Darkrasp. In the end i have the feeling there could have been better choices than Elysium for a partner. Also i hope, that maybe some answers can be given to some of my questions. Also i want to say, that on a personal level i can understand Asuras decision and the crisis management that followed. But then again nobody needs some guy that spreads around empathy to a person he has no real connection to. Greetings Ps: That Xaverius so far keeps his ironic distance to such a heavy topic botters me even more :D.
  10. I see this as a positive development :), congrats!
  11. Thanks for the update :), as always a joy to read.
  12. Ok, that helped me a bit :). But still you didn't pick up on the question onCrogges planning with Elysium. Will it be temporary to finish the stuff he began or is it a probably long-term-commitment? I totally understand that there is no definite answer to this point when Crogges does not answer it himself (and even then only time can tell), but maybe you also have come to pick up some statements concerning this matter from the staff or from newer developments. Greetings
  13. I thought Crogge was still onboard the Elysium-project to finish the work he had started (forum overhaul aso.) when the Legacy-Network was still current. This information is based on an announcement by Asura or Darkrasp, which seems to be not present anymore in the announcement-section, so i cannot back this up (nearly all announcements concerning the LGN are not there anymore, probably to not confuse new arrivals). So the information you present us with is new to me and cannot be found in the forums as far as i remember (i'm sorry if i overlooked something). Respectively my understanding of this is solely based on what you said above. I heard that, project-wise, Crogge is not directly related to Crestfall. But i always identified him with the staff here. So does this now mean he will stay with Elysium as an active member of their Project? Or is it still the case, that he just wants to finish something he started there as some kind of work- and general ethic? Greetings Polyphem
  14. Rock from Hamburg, Germany, relatively unknown, quite atmospheric :3.
  15. Holy Sibyl, that escalated quickly!